« Brookdale Dog Park Has Neighbors Growling | Main | More Montclair Lawsuits? »

Tragedy At The YMCA

Wednesday, February 13, 2008

Montclair YMCA members and staff were in shock Saturday, when a nine-year-old boy from West Orange collapsed on the basketball court during an afternoon game. We received some information from Dawn McFadden at the YMCA about the tragedy.

The youngster collapsed from a severe asthma attack. The father, who was in the gym at the time, was carrying an inhaler and tried to administer it to his son. There was a nurse in the crowd who tried to help, as did many of the YMCA staff members. Police and ambulance were called, and according to staff members, the child was rushed to St. Barnabas Hospital.

The boy died within an hour of his collapse. Chief of Police David Sabagh says the family wishes to mourn in privacy. McFadden told Baristanet "we tried everything to help and assist the boy and his family. This is devastating to the family and the YMCA community."

Noon Update:
YMCA President and CEO Tom Boyton told us: The boy received immediate medical attention. A staff member pushed one of the "Code Blue" buttons which are all around the facility, called 911. Emergency trained staff administered CPR, and police/ambulance showed up quickly. "We located the mother who was at another location, picked her up and a staff member drove her to the hospital. We're not sure when the boy expired. This is a tragic occurrence."

Posted by Annette Batson on February 13, 2008 11:44 AM
Email this story |
 

so sad, really tragic.

Posted by ROC | February 13, 2008 12:03 PM
 

Good Lord. What a horror. I hope his family doesn't sue the Y. They have panic buttons all over the place, defib devices et. all. I can't believe this kid couldn't be saved. I'm in shock.

Posted by MellonBrush | February 13, 2008 12:06 PM
 

Not to take away from the tragicness of this, but isn't Mountainside a few blocks away verus St. Barnabus which is easily a 20 minute drive?

Posted by ackme | February 13, 2008 12:33 PM
 

Very sad. My condolences to the boy's family. It sounds like the folks who tried to help him did all they could.

It still amazes me that people can die from asthma this way.

ackme, I haven't been in Mountainside in a long time, but from what I know of the past it is not where you want to go if you have a serious problem. St. B's is a real emergency room. I daresay you'd even be better off at University Hospital in Newark.

Posted by State Street Pete | February 13, 2008 1:49 PM
 

I hear you on that, but I just thought it could have been better than such a long drive.

University Hospital is our state trauma center. If I get shot, take me there.

Posted by ackme | February 13, 2008 1:56 PM
 

St. Barnabas has a pediatric E.R., Mountainside does not.

Posted by lordfezzik | February 13, 2008 2:34 PM
 

Ah I see, thanks fezzik.

Posted by State Street Pete | February 13, 2008 2:46 PM
 

Wow, this is so awful. My heart goes out to the family, as well as the Y staffers who I'm sure did everything they could.

I'll be giving my kids an extra hug tonight.

Posted by Kay | February 13, 2008 3:39 PM
 

INCONCEIVABLE!

Posted by ackme | February 13, 2008 3:48 PM
 

I would still think that they would go to the nearest hospital for immediate treatment. As an asthmatic myself and having been hospitilzed as an adult because of it I can attest to the horrible feeling I got when reading this story. But if time is of the essence, I would opt for the closest medical facility. Who knows if that would have saved him - it could have been beyond that at that point but 5 minutes vs 20 makes a huge difference IMO.

Posted by Anne Prince | February 13, 2008 3:56 PM
 

Anne-

Pediatric ER's have supplies fitted for children while regular ER's have a very limited supply or have to make an adult piece work for a child. The closes peds units to Montclair are St. Barnabas or St. Joseph in Patterson. My pediatrician told me to demand the pediatric ER in an emergency and not to take "NO" for an answer.

Posted by lordfezzik | February 13, 2008 4:48 PM
 

"My pediatrician told me to demand the pediatric ER in an emergency and not to take "NO" for an answer."

Seem like an awfully big blanket statement to me. For myself it would depend on the injury.

Posted by ROC | February 13, 2008 4:59 PM
 

The two top rated hospitals in our area are Beth Israel in Newark and St. Barnabas in West Orange. The fastest rising in care lately has been Clara Maas in Belleville. Close behind the prior two that are equal, according to some magazine I was reading in the dentist's office recently. A Medical article. Possibly NJ Monthly, but not sure.

Posted by Sandy | February 13, 2008 6:50 PM
 

How heartbreaking! Mountainside Hospital is a travesty. I was there for one emergency room visit for a badly sprained ankle. There were no physicians available, I was stored in a freezing room for hours and there was absolutely no sense of concern for this patient.

I hated it; however, the ambulance would not take me to my hospital of choice, St. Barnabas.

Posted by surprise | February 13, 2008 9:49 PM
 

I went to Clara Mass emergency last Monday. It was 12:30 AM and the place was packed.

Fortunately, I was triaged right in and within the hour was treated and released. Dr. Santos was very nice and the nurse who actually worked on me was great, even though her English was not terriffic.

It took my wife about 8 minutes to get me down there. They also have a nice ER parking area too.

Posted by MellonBrush | February 15, 2008 10:08 AM
 

MellonBrush -- everything OK?

Posted by Liz | February 15, 2008 10:14 AM
 

I'm ok now. Had surgery and there was complication. I'm ok now.

:)

Posted by MellonBrush | February 15, 2008 10:19 AM
 

Glad to hear that, MB.

Posted by Miss Martta | February 15, 2008 10:20 AM
 

It was a plumbing problem. ;)

Posted by MellonBrush | February 15, 2008 10:20 AM
 

Ackame - paramedics are able to do everything a hospital can do for a kid in V-fib (this case), aside from cardiac surgery, which would obviously not have helped.

Everybody else - Mountainside is a fine hospital. In a real emergency (not your broken ankle or whatever), you're going to a specialty facility anyways. Kid? St. Joh's or Barnabas. Burn? Barnabas also. Cardiac? St. Mike's in Newark. More-than-a-cut trauma? University.

Mountainside and Clara Maas aren't specialty hospitals. In a real emergency, you don't go there.

ROC - she's correct. Any competent medic/ambulance crew chief will not need to be told, but any pedi-call goes to a pedi-ER unless they code on you in the back of the rig and you don't have medics (then you go to the nearest hospital, and they transport from there).

Anne Prince - No, he wouldn't have been OK; kids in arrest bounce back very easily if there's no underlying heart problem. Usually it's a breathing thing (like athsma)... once breathing is restored, heart function usually returns spontaneously. It didn't; there was probably more going on than athsma in this case.

I doubt the transport took 20 minutes - there was an escort and blocked-off intersections (was on Eagle Rock at the time).

Posted by rmd | February 15, 2008 3:22 PM
 
You must log into Vbulletin to post Comments. Log in below.

Not Registered? Click Here to register.

Adriana O'Toole Homes

Carol Tangorra for all your real estate needs

Your Color Source








Weather
Movies
TV

Gmail
NJ Transit
DeCamp
People Search
Google Maps
Dictionary
Google News
Homeland Security
Essex County News
High School Sports
» MONTCLAIR LINKS
ABOUT
Official Montclair Website
Montclair Center
Montclair Schools
Montclair Community Pre-K
Montclair State University
American Towns
Town Profile
THE ARTS
Arts Montclair
Montclair Art Museum
Montclair Arts Council
Peak Performances
Youth Orchestras of Essex County
ATTRACTIONS
New Jersey Jackals
Presby Iris Gardens
Van Vleck Gardens
COMMUNITY
Montclair Adult School
Montclair Public Library
Montclair YMCA
Mountainside Health Foundation
Red Cross
Toni's Kitchen
COMMUTING
The Clever Commute
Montclair-Boonton Line Train Schedule
FORUMS/BLOGS
Montclair Journal
Montclair Watercooler
Montclair Unmoderated
NJ.com Montclair Forum
ORGANIZATIONS
Bike Montclair
Brookdale Park Conservancy
Friends of Anderson Park
League of Women Voters of the Montclair Area
MEWS
Montclair Engineers
MFEE/Montclair Reads
Montclair Fund for Women
Montclair Historical Society
Montclair PTA
Montclair Wildlife
Outpost in the Burbs
OTHER
New Jersey Life and Leisure
VillageRadio

» GLEN RIDGE LINKS
» BLOOMFIELD LINKS
» OUTER BARISTAVILLE
» OF INTEREST BLOGS
BARISTAS
jjschiffer.com
Madeleine Bake Shop
Politics of Place
Read Me, Love Me, Buy the Book
stopkatie.com
Wanderful!!!
ARTISTS

Artisan Studio Underground
Artist / Blacksmith Charlie Spademan
Dust and Rust
habit-image-reaction
I Will Kick Your Ass For World Peace
Regia Richest
CULTURE
Authentic Organizations
La Tertulia
FOOD
Cat Food
Chowhound
Hungry Chef
Mano a Vino
Table Hopping with Rosie
FORUMS
E-gullet NJ
Know Neighborhood
Springsteen Forum
GARDENING
The Gardeners Apprentice
The Gardening Guru
GO GREEN
Green Jersey
Reuse and Recycle in Montclair
HEALTH
Medicana
NEW JERSEY
Bada Bing Blog
Blog Net News NJ
Jersey Side
NJ.com
NJHotShots
NJ My Way
Weird NJ
OF USE
Craig's List NJ
PetFinder
Urban Dictionary
PARENTING
Au Pair Mom
Dante's Inferno with Children
FinSlippy
Looky Daddy
The Mamahood
Raisinology
Who's the Grown Up?
PERSONAL
55 Secret Street
Anovelista
CarreFemme
The Daily Doormatt
Detox Moxie
From Bloomberg to Bloomfield
I Hate Decamp
Inclusive Ceremonies
Little Brown Pen
Man With a Pen
Martta's World
Maui Girl's Meanderings
The Media Drop
Meg McGonagall
MOM & Pop Culture
My Life as a Rabid Blog
Richieville
RZ's Blog
Tina Bell
Snake Oil Sam
The Society for Conscious Craft
Wellness Woman
Wine Lover's Journal
Yenta Diva
POLITICAL
Gold Finch Tech
New Jersey Politics Unusual
REAL ESTATE
Crystal Ball Real Estate
Eco Realty

Email us to link your blog