« Sunday Night Just Got Harder | Main | Join The Team To Stop Domestic Violence »

Whose Wedding (Podcast) Is It Anyway?

Monday, September 29, 2008

Two wedding podcast businesses -- one from Livingston, the other, Belleville -- are battling it out in court. From the Star Ledger...

The Wedding Podcast Network vs. Wedding Podcast Channel case is one of a growing number of website disputes ending up in the courts, said Matt Zimmerman, senior staff attorney with the Electronic Frontier Foundation, a California-based nonprofit group that specializes in free speech on the internet.

The Ehrlichs, of Livingston [pictured], allege [Ralph] Mucci is "cyber-stalking" them. He stole their wedding podcasting idea, copied their website format, modeled his shows after theirs, called their sponsors, stole their guests and created mass confusion about which wedding podcasting website is which, according to the lawsuit.

Mucci admits the sites are similar, but he says they are not identical. He denies he has done anything wrong.

"It's like saying Starbucks can't sell coffee because Dunkin' Donuts sells coffee," Mucci said. "The ideas and the concepts that the Wedding Podcast Network displays are not unique ideas. ... There is no copyright on that."

What do you think?

Posted by Liz George on September 29, 2008 1:50 PM
|
 

I dunno. The sites don't look anything alike, not in the least. (You need to have Java installed to see the second one). I'm with Mucci but I'm not a lawyer. I guess it needs to be determine if Mucci "stole" any ideas from the couple.

There seems to be a lot of "fluff" on this site today as the economy cracks around us. House just voted no on the bailout, stocks are falling...

Oh please. The market is potentially big enough for two (or more) players. The Ehrlichs need to grow a spine and accept that perhaps their business is suffering because of the state of the economy. A wedding podcast? Really? The whole idea is kind of ludicrous in itself.

The only somewhat legit issue I see is the similarity in names, but that's only really a legal issue of the Ehrlichs have a valid trademark for the name "Wedding Podcast" -- in which they could then use to force Mucci to change his business name. But they can;t force him to go out of business. The laws simply don't work that way.

Ian: Baristanet consistently post content relevant to Montclair and its surrounding area? You'll have to go back a year or so to find that. In the meantime, enjoy the stories about dogs, weddings, television shows, and national politics. No "hyperlocal" blogging here. Enjoy the fluff!

It depends. The wedding podcast idea isn't protectable, but it seems Mucci went out of his way to create confusion and he tried lead potential customers to believe he was associated with an established business trading under a similar name. If the details discussed in the article are true it would seem that he was trying to make money by trading on the the goodwill generated by someone else's trademark. That's illeagal.

um...that would be "illegal"

Ummm...wedding podcasts? Really? So the sanctity of marriage is now equal to learning what happened on "Lost" last week?

At least its one step closer to Gay marriage being legal.

This guy, Mucci, sounds like such a loser. I have a store and what this loser is doing on the internet is no different than standing outside the front door and soliciting the clients as they leave. The Ehrlichs clearly had the idea first, why can't Mucci come up with his own ideas, why does he need to copy someone else. It causes confusion.

If one owner was in china and the other in America, this would not be an issue. The fact that the only two idiots have the same idea live within 20 minutes of eachother creates the problem. now would be a good time to start a parody site, and use a search optimization program to rank higher on google

Leave a comment

Baristanet Comment Policy: Commenters on Baristanet.com are responsible for all legal consequences arising from their comments, including libel, infringement of copyright or actions that threaten a third party. By submitting a comment, you agree to indemnify Baristanet LLC, its partners and employees from any legal action arising from your comments. Report inappropriate comments to comments@baristanet.com. For trouble with registration or commenting, write to comments@baristanet.com.









Weather
Movies
TV

Gmail
NJ Transit
DeCamp
People Search
Google Maps
Dictionary
Google News
Homeland Security
Essex County News
High School Sports
» MONTCLAIR LINKS
ABOUT
Official Montclair Website
Montclair Center
Montclair Schools
Montclair Community Pre-K
Montclair State University
American Towns
Town Profile
THE ARTS
Arts Montclair
Montclair Art Museum
Montclair Arts Council
Peak Performances
Youth Orchestras of Essex County
ATTRACTIONS
New Jersey Jackals
Presby Iris Gardens
Van Vleck Gardens
COMMUNITY
COPE Center
HOMECorp
Montclair Adult School
Montclair Counseling Center
Montclair Public Library
Montclair YMCA
Mountainside Health Foundation
Montclair State Community Page
Red Cross
Toni's Kitchen
COMMUTING
The Clever Commute
Montclair-Boonton Line Train Schedule
FORUMS/BLOGS
Montclair Journal
Montclair Watercooler
Montclair Unmoderated
NJ.com Montclair Forum
Montclair Kids
ORGANIZATIONS
Boy Scout Troop 12
Bike Montclair
Brookdale Park Conservancy
Friends of Anderson Park
League of Women Voters of the Montclair Area
MEWS
Montclair Engineers
MFEE/Montclair Reads
Montclair Fund for Women
Montclair Historical Society
Montclair PTA
Montclair Wildlife
Outpost in the Burbs
OTHER
New Jersey Life and Leisure
VillageRadio

» GLEN RIDGE LINKS
» BLOOMFIELD LINKS
» OUTER BARISTAVILLE
» OF INTEREST BLOGS
BARISTAS
Diva Indoors
jjschiffer.com
Madeleine Bake Shop
stopkatie.com
Tom Biro
Wanderful!!!
ARTISTS
Artist / Blacksmith Charlie Spademan
Dust and Rust
habit-image-reaction
I Will Kick Your Ass For World Peace
Regia Richest
CULTURE
Authentic Organizations
FOOD
Mano a Vino
Table Hopping with Rosie
FORUMS
E-gullet NJ
Know Neighborhood
Springsteen Forum
GARDENING
The Gardeners Apprentice
GO GREEN
Green Jersey
HUMOR
Late But Soon
NEW JERSEY
Bada Bing Blog
Blog Net News NJ
NJ.com
NJHotShots
NJ My Way
Weird NJ
OF USE
North Jersey Craigslist
PetFinder
Urban Dictionary
PARENTING
Au Pair Mom
FinSlippy
Looky Daddy
The Mamahood
PERSONAL
55 Secret Street
Anovelista
Barbara's Footnotes
The Daily Doormatt
Detox Moxie
Green Music Life
I Hate Decamp
Inclusive Ceremonies
Joe's Journal
Little Brown Pen
Living With Cancer
Maui Girl's Meanderings
Meg McGonagall
MOM & Pop Culture
Sarah Siegel Stories
Wine Lover's Journal
POLITICAL
New Jersey Politics Unusual
REAL ESTATE
Crystal Ball Real Estate
Eco Realty

Email us to link your blog