Since word got out that Montclair’s iconic coffee bar-hangout – Cafe Eclectic – is being squeezed out after 16 years on the block, landlord Dominic Restaino has been getting an earful.
Restaino, owner of Cuban Pete’s, told Baristanet his customers have been coming to his restaurant complaining: “WHY, WHY are you kicking them out? How could you do this? We love Cafe Eclectic, let them stay!’”
Restaino, who bought the building in July 2010, called Baristanet to tell his side of the story. After 16 years as a tenant, Valentin’s rent is below market price, according to Restaino. The building Cafe Eclectic occupies is actually two storefronts, and Restaino says he wants to rent them at fair market value.
“I love Cafe Eclectic, I’ve had good times there, and I like sending my customers there for coffee and dessert. I asked Valentin if he wanted to stay after his lease expired, however not at the current rent, which is about $3,500/month. Julio told me he has other plans,” says Restaino.
According to Restaino, he and Valentin are still friends. “I’m not putting up any “FOR LEASE” signs until Cafe Eclectic moves out. I’m trying to be a gentleman about it,” he said.
As for the next tenants, he’s holding out for another cafe. “I want a cafe to stay there. I have three people who are interested, and I’ve already said no to a hair salon and clothing store.” (Of course with Restaino, anything is possible and things could change. And will the building go green?)
No matter what Restaino does, for die-hard fans of Cafe Eclectic, nothing else can replace it.